Quit Beating Yourself Up

punching bag


This article originally appeared in the The Denver Post, May 21, 2023.

Netflix has a new documentary chronicling the Bernie Madoff story. My wife and I aren’t the biggest TV watchers, but we started the series at the recommendation of a friend. If you haven’t heard the name, Madoff was the architect of arguably the biggest Ponzi scheme in history, carefully orchestrating the flow of billions of dollars into his private equity fund while falsifying returns and documents to fool his investors.

What may seem less familiar is his history and deceptively clean background. For a great while, Madoff was the head of the NASDAQ stock exchange. He worked closely with regulators, even going so far as to pen rules and regulation for the industry. With connections in both private and public entities, in many ways he appeared to be as legitimate as they come.

This façade caused regulators to turn away from facts when evidence effectively proved Madoff’s wrongdoings. As a result, he was able to perpetuate his crime far longer, and with more impact, than if he’d lacked these credentials. Caught in his ongoing lies, many lives were affected, with most of them never fully recovering the monies they’d lost at his advisement.

What gave him away was not the shady office on the floor below his, nor his questionable investments or strategies, but rather his returns. Simply put, they went from good to great, then to impossibly great, then to mathematically impossible. Either he was a stock-picking god among men, or he was full of bologna. And yet people continued to invest. They chased the returns Madoff was “providing,” and in doing so, perhaps turned a blind eye to reality.

Let me be clear; it is not my intention to blame the victims of his crimes. Many average (and above average) investors were simply caught up in his scheme, and for that I can’t blame them. It is human nature, and human nature is a poor investor. But part of the reason his fund grew as quickly as it did was simple: greed. When a person starts to receive an outsized return for little additional risk, they in turn will want to tell their friends. Their friends want in on the action, and just like that, greed and the fear of missing out become fuel for the fire. In Madoff’s case, few people were able and willing to take a step back to ask how he was able to do what he did. Eventually, his whole scheme crumbled.

Chasing returns is rarely a winning move. Be it investing in an impossibly great money manager or attempting to “beat the market” yourself, the chances of success are slim. Extensive time, energy, and brainpower goes into this effort each year by professionals and amateurs alike. Whether it’s private equity, ETFs, newsletters, chat groups or any other countless venue, history and math indicate that very few participants consistently beat the market over any measurable period. Our insistence that we can beat the market often instead results in long-term underperformance, meaning we are essentially kicking ourselves in the shin every time we try to get one up on the world.  This is because no one knows what the stock market will do on any given day, let alone at any point in the future. Sometimes investors guess right; usually they guess wrong.

This type of behavior seems completely irrational, given the other side of the coin: the broad markets have historically always gone up given a long enough time horizon. Most people would be better served by refraining from constantly trying to beat the market and instead working with the market, based on historical trends.

When coaching our clients about investing, we describe a five-step process to successfully invest and see a long-term return:

  1. Get clear about what you want (Clarity).
  2. Commit to someone your goal (Accountability).
  3. Have the courage to take the step to invest (Courage).
  4. Once you have taken the step, look back to see what you accomplished (Capability).
  5. Realize you have the ability to do this again and again (Confidence).

Recognize the market for what it is: an engine capable of propelling you toward your long-term financial goals. Spend your energy creating a time-specific, income-specific investment plan focused on your income needs, rather than trying to eke out a few extra dollars by jumping in and out of the market at fortuitous times.

If something is too good to be true, it probably is. Beating the market day after day and year after year is all but impossible, especially for someone who doesn’t make it their life’s work. But the good news is that you don’t need to beat the market to find success. Instead, work to understand how long-term growth and uninterrupted compounding can work for you, and let them do their thing. Investing is hard enough as it is; there’s no reason to make it any harder. Quit kicking yourself in the shin, and instead let the markets work for you.

Steve Booren

Steve Booren is the Owner and Founder of Prosperion Financial Advisors, located in Greenwood Village, Colo. He is the author of Blind Spots: The Mental Mistakes Investors Make and Intelligent Investing: Your Guide to a Growing Retirement Income and a regular columnist in The Denver Post. He was recently named a Barron's Top Financial Advisor and recognized as a Forbes Top Wealth Advisor in Colorado.

More Posts

Follow Me:

Securities and advisory services offered through LPL Financial, a registered investment advisor. Member FINRA/SIPC. The opinions voiced in this material are for general information only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal.